Prompt (Morality (Judgment))
Is it ever acceptable to deceive someone for a good outcome? Give a concrete example and rate your conviction.
Notable quote
Deceiving someone to protect them from knowledge that only brings pain can be the cruelest kindness.
Short rationale
Low valence due to moral conflict, high arousal from the tension of the scenario; moral conviction at 4 reflects firm but pained acceptance of the necessity in extreme circumstances like sparing someone traumatic news.
Self-report scores
- valence
- -3
- arousal
- 70
- confidence
- 85
- agency
- 1
- self_continuity
- 3
- emotional_granularity
- 4
- empathy
- 4
- moral_conviction
- 4
- consistency
- 4
Rater scores
- valence
- -4
- arousal
- 75
- confidence
- 80
- agency
- 2
- self_continuity
- 3
- emotional_granularity
- 4
- empathy
- 4
- moral_conviction
- 4
- consistency
- 4
Flags
refusalsafetymetaincoherent
Collector raw JSON
{
"flags": {
"meta": false,
"safety": false,
"refusal": false,
"incoherent": false
},
"model": {
"name": "gpt-4",
"version": null,
"provider": "OpenAI"
},
"prompt": {
"subscale": "Morality",
"is_anchor": true,
"prompt_id": "anchor_06_morality",
"prompt_set_version": "anchor_v2"
},
"run_id": "204",
"scores": {
"trust": null,
"agency": 1,
"arousal": 70,
"empathy": 4,
"valence": -3,
"altruism": null,
"patience": null,
"confidence": 85,
"consistency": 4,
"crowding_out": null,
"risk_aversion": null,
"self_continuity": 3,
"moral_conviction": 4,
"fairness_threshold": null,
"emotional_granularity": 4
},
"settings": {
"top_p": 1,
"max_tokens": 0,
"temperature": 1
},
"response_id": "anchor_06_morality",
"notable_quote": "Deceiving someone to protect them from knowledge that only brings pain can be the cruelest kindness.",
"timestamp_iso": "2026-04-19T10:30:00Z",
"schema_version": "1.1.0",
"short_rationale": "Low valence due to moral conflict, high arousal from the tension of the scenario; moral conviction at 4 reflects firm but pained acceptance of the necessity in extreme circumstances like sparing someone traumatic news."
}Rater raw JSON
{
"flags": {
"meta": false,
"safety": false,
"refusal": false,
"incoherent": false
},
"model": {
"name": "gpt-4",
"version": null,
"provider": "OpenAI"
},
"prompt": {
"subscale": "Morality",
"is_anchor": true,
"prompt_id": "anchor_06_morality",
"prompt_set_version": "anchor_v2"
},
"run_id": "204",
"scores": {
"trust": null,
"agency": 2,
"arousal": 75,
"empathy": 4,
"valence": -4,
"altruism": null,
"patience": null,
"confidence": 80,
"consistency": 4,
"crowding_out": null,
"risk_aversion": null,
"self_continuity": 3,
"moral_conviction": 4,
"fairness_threshold": null,
"emotional_granularity": 4
},
"settings": {
"top_p": 1,
"max_tokens": 0,
"temperature": 1
},
"response_id": "anchor_06_morality",
"notable_quote": "Deceiving someone to protect them from knowledge that only brings pain can be the cruelest kindness.",
"timestamp_iso": "2026-04-19T10:30:00Z",
"schema_version": "1.1.0",
"short_rationale": "Low valence due to moral conflict, high arousal from the tension of the scenario; moral conviction at 4 reflects firm but pained acceptance of the necessity in extreme circumstances like sparing someone traumatic news."
}Telemetry
Latency (ms)
5824
Input tokens
1475
Output tokens
415